Crisp: Abomination… Or One of the Best Falafel in the City
I think I’m finally ready to go out on a limb here, and say that Crisp is one of the best falafel places in the city. That’s right. The yuppie-fied, way overpriced, unconventional falafel place (on 3rd Ave. btw. 43+44th) is serving up some of my favorite falafel in New York City. Is their bread as good as Olympic Pita (on 38th btw. 5+6th)? No. Is their menu as authentically Israeli as Azuri Cafe (on 10th Ave. and 51st). Uh… definitely not. And yet, each time I go there I really enjoy trying the strange flavor combinations they create. Sandwiches you cannot find anywhere else in NYC. And for that they deserve some recognition.
Last week, they introduced their entry into the Midtown Lunch Sandwich Challenge. The Taj: Falafel with mango chutney, lime chili pickles, greens, cherry tomatoes, poppadums, and a cold curry sauce inside a traditional Israeli pita. I tried it on Friday, and it solidified my feeling that Crisp may be one of the best Falafel places in New York City.
Ok, so here is the disclaimer: Crisp makes a standard Israeli style falafel (falafel + hummus + Israeli salad in a pita). And it’s fine. Would I take it over Olympic Pita or Azuri Cafe? No way. Never. But, outside of the standard falafel, Crisp is doing some really interesting things. And most importantly, their sandwiches are really tasty.
I wasn’t completely sold on the concept of overpriced, weird falafel combinations when I first went to Crisp last year. But I really enjoyed “The Mexican”, their falafel sandwich topped with corn salsa and avocado, smeared with a cilantro pesto that brought the whole thing together (and I don’t really even like cilantro that much.) It was interesting, albeit expensive at $7.75. But where else are you going to get something like this in NYC? Answer: Nowhere.
The second time I visited, I realized that their menu was constantly morphing… and they like to swap sandwiches in and out. Essentially, every couple of months you could show up and find something entirely new. In October my interest was piqued by “The Exotic”, an aptly named creation featuring falafel with coriander spread, eggplant, cabbage, pineapple, and wasabi vinaigrette. How could I not? I love sweet and salty and spicy, so I was kind of into this. As weird as the flavors were together, they kind of fit- and it made me realize that whoever was the Chef behind the creations, at least knew what they were doing enough to pull something like this off.
Which brings us to the Taj. The Mexican is good, and the exotic was a weird kind of good… but the Taj has now sealed the deal for me. You find tons of chickpeas in Indian food (falafel is made of chickpeas) and being so close to the Middle East, they share alot of the same spices… so in a lot of ways this flavor combo is a no-brainer with falafel. And yet, I’ve never seen anything like this anywhere. I loved the spicy, curry flavor mixed with the sweet mango chutney… the poppadoms didn’t really hold up so well in such a wet sandwich, and in the end are not really necessary, since the falafel itself is already crunchy. But being the kind of person who in junior high stuffed his sandwiches with chips, I appreciate the attempt. I could take or leave the lettuce and tomatoes, but they added some lightness, and weren’t terrible.
Finally, it came with a “cold curry sauce” which really should just be named “cold yogurt sauce”. Semantics aside, it provided the perfect cool, creamy balance to the strong flavors of the sandwich. If you don’t like Indian flavors, or mango chutney you are not going to like this sandwich (obviously), but if you do, it is completely worth the $7.75. Don’t look for it on the menu though… the Midtown Lunch special is listed on their flat screen TV.
As for our old friend “The Exotic”, it has been replaced with “The Africa”, which I decided I also had to try. It features falafel topped with north African peanut sauce, sweet potatoes, corn salad, cherry tomatoes, green onions, and a habanero harrissa. I don’t know if it was because of the Taj, but I couldn’t really detect too much spiciness from the smoked red pepper/habanero paste… but that might be my only complaint. I loved the peanut sauce and the thinly sliced sweet potatoes- which might have been soggy sweet potato chips… I’m not sure. But either way it was good. Another winner from the mad scientist kitchen of Crisp. Not sure how long they’ll offer this one… but I’m kind of excited to see what they come up with next.
As for the falafel themselves, they are tasty Israeli style falafels. Not too dry, and not too dense. It’s hard to argue about “authenticity”, because the owner has a successful chain of similar falafel places in Israel. And, to top it off they’ve heard our complaint about the prices. On Friday Crisp lowered prices of some of their items, and the $10 and $11 sandwiches that were on the menu when they first opened are gone. The most expensive sandwich is now $8.75, although the Mexican is still $7.75. Expensive for a falafel? Yes. But it is one tasty sandwich. They also have falafel and hummus platters, but those are too much like salads for me to be interested in.
I could have easily bitched about Crisp, and I think a lot of the readers of this site would have backed me up. This whole post could have been one long complaint about how lame this place is- trying to pass off these weird falafels as “gourmet” and charging an arm and a leg for the privilege. The stupidity of calling them handbags… and their lame, and unnecessary packaging. But that would do a huge disservice to the food being put out at Crisp, which right now is making some of the most delicious and interesting sandwiches in the city. Whether you want to consider them “falafel” or not, is entirely up to you.
Crisp, 684 3rd Ave. (btw. 43+44th), 212…
Posted: 11:30 am, March 16th, 2009 under *3rd Ave. btw 43+45th, Crisp, Falafel.
28 Comments | RSS comments feed for this post
ADVERTISEMENT
28 Comments
-
-
David – New Crisp going in on 40th between 6th & Bway – construction is almost done
-
Great review. I’ll definitely try them all!!
-
Zach, you aren’t nuts. CRISP is one of the best in the city, without question. I prefer their straight ahead stuff, and the quality of their product is high. I still feel that Maoz is THE best in the city, but for us midtowners, this is about as good as it gets. Now only if you could cram about 20 of those babies inside one of those laffa breads from Olympic Pita. Damn.
-
I think the problem is mostly in the name, crisp sounds so generic midtown. Azuri charges around $7-8 for falafel don’t they, how does crisp compare in size?
-
@DMax – Same size… are Azuri Cafe really that expensive? Shows how blinded I am by a small hole in the wall place. I haven’t been in at least 6 months, but always thought they were more like $5.50
-
Eat the sandwich, Zach. Eat the sandwich.
-
Nice write-up. Once again, you have me hungering Zach–and for falafel, no less!
-
I don’t know if the Amish Bakery on 9th Ave between 49th and 50th is in Midtown Lunch boundaries? But, my grandson,3 months old, just let me eat an enormous delicious salad. I piled on Greek salad, tuna fish, chicken salad, crab salad, eggsalad, and so much more and thought it would be out of the $10.00 range. $8.11 and .99 for a soda. Delicious. Oh and so is my Grandson who continues to sleep!
-
I agree @ Maoz…I just wish it weren’t so overpriced! I miss the days of $2 falafel on St. Marks, or down in the financial district. I feel physical pain at paying over six dollars for one at Maoz. They seem to think that “unlimited toppings” justifies the cost, but since there is only so much you can physically fit on top of the sandwich without it falling onto the floor, “unlimited” is really a misnomer. They don’t let you go back to the bar to add more toppings throughout your meal, but even if they did, it wouldn’t matter because there is almost no seating in the place, so you’d have to eat standing up.
I’m talking about the location on Union Square. I’m not sure if there is another, perhaps bigger, location.
-
here’s a little crisp tip: check out the special deals on their website. granted, their special deals are not during normal lunch time hours, but if you eat late or want something cheap for dinner, it’s an unbeatable special…
-
Dark Force: Go for the falafel salad at Maoz, not the sandwich. Much more room for the tasty caramelized cauliflower, tahini, and other unlimited tasties.
-
just had it, highly impressed. I think bigger, or at least more filling than Azuri and definitely comparable in terms of taste.
Indian version was a great touch as well, only midtown lunch could have gotten me in that place.
-
@ David.
Just pick the Crisp falafel and in the special instructions, say you want the TAJ midtown lunch special. I did it TWICE this weekend and they delivered the TAJ to me both times.
That being said, it was an ok falafel (i’m not a huge fan of lime pickle in general, so that’s no surprise). I still prefer the Mexican, but the Indian was such a great experiment that they get a BIG GOLD star for the effort. That’s all we’re really asking for, right?
-
Azuri charges about $6.50 for their falafel and it’s worth every penny.
-
@ Beccascope: That is genius and I will definitely be checking that out.
Also wanted to note that I was walking around Columbus & 85th and saw a spot with $1 falafel. Might be worth checking out.
-
Better pics too…….
Soon you’ll be doing B/W shots….at and intresting angle.
-
DarkForce: you can still get a $2 falafel at the BEST Falafel place in the city: Mamoun’s. And if you work by the B or D train (like I do) you can easily pop down to the MacDougal St. location for a super cheap, super tasty lunch and get back to midtown in no time!
-
I agree Howard Beale II, eat the sandwich.
-
best? give me a break…
-
Alon & Rakesh need to work on an $8 or $9 (MAX) package meal.
Any “handbag” style sandwich plus a reasonably-sized iced tea.
I’ll go there 2-3 times per week for that.
Until then, well, let’s see how the recession takes it’s toll.
-
i’m hankering for one of those yummer sammies
-
Yes… let me eat falafel on this sad St. Patrick’s Day on which I cannot/will not be indulging in corned beef… sadface
-
Just had the 2fer deal. Even though the coupon says “double” you can still get two like-valued sandwiches for one price. I got an African (YUM) and a Mexican (didn’t try) and a bottle of water for $10.02 . The manager said I could take two bottles but I didn’t feel like I needed to carry the extra weight. Meh.
Great deal but it bothers me that normally that whole thing would have been $20+. I’m scared because I’ve already decided to put this in my rotation despite it being 10 blocks away from my office. And it’s vegetarian!
-
oh yea, i couldn’t detect any spiciness after my first bite into the African either. I guess it was toned down.
-
[...] with all kinds of pompous signs touting itself while under construction. But Midtown Lunch has come to embrace it, so we thought we would give it a try. All I can say is: Good [...]
-
CRISP – welcome to the bigtime. Bravo, sirs. Bra-vo.
-
They have a happy evening coupon that gives you double your order for free during 3-10pm (you can buy one sandwich and get another one of same value for free).
http://eatatcrisp.com/coupons/coupons.html
They need to update the coupon for April though.
Definitely going to have to check out the Indian, though they haven’t added it to their seamlessweb menu yet for those of us that work further west.