Potbelly’s Sugar Cookie is Another Winner
Since I was so delighted by Potbelly’s Oatmeal & Chocolate Chip Cookie, I decided to go for a second round and try out their sugar cookie. Sugar cookies can be a tough dessert to pull off right, but evidently Potbelly has their dessert recipes down pat because this was another winner.
The cookie is the same size and price as the oatmeal chocolate chip, meaning that you get a big cookie for under $2. Also, just like the other cookie, this one was chewy with a little crispiness around the edges. The cookie has a pleasant amount of vanilla flavor and is sweet without being cloying. Plus there’s the added bonus of crunch from sugar sprinkled on top! The two wins in a row is making me excited to try their third dessert, the Dreambar.
Potbelly Sandwich Shop has two locations in Midtown. One on 44th btw. Lex+3rd and one in the Rock Center Concourse.