Midtown Happy Hour: Subway Inn

If you like to eat, chances are you like to drink (read: a lot of you are freakin’ lushes), so I thought maybe it was time to introduce a happy hour column to the site. Every week we’ll post about a different bar in Midtown that fits the Midtown Lunch mentality: unhealthy food, not lame (unless it’s lame in a cool way), and most importantly… cheap. This week our one and only Happy Hour Correspondent Mamacita (yes, the commenters managed to scare off our other contributor) hits up the Subway Inn, a hygenically dubious bar in Midtown East…

Midtown Happy Hour: Subway Inn

What hasn’t already been said about this celebrated yet inconspicuous bar? The Subway Inn has been the stumbling ground for crowd-weary and thirsty locals since 1937. In sharp contrast to its neighbor (the regal Bloomingdales) Subway Inn is small, dark and dirty. Many an old-timer has made their dent on those bar stools and all these years later you can still find some sitting on their favorite seat.

I have to admit, it had been a while since I last visited. I think it may have been in 2004 and at that point the bar still truly belonged to the hunched drunkards and working class Joes. Subway Inn had yet to see the dive bar fame that has popularized many a bar in the past few years. The ceiling back then, as I recall, was heavily textured with fuzzy stalactites of greasy dust bunnies. This filth proceeded to cascade down the walls with its shaggy smut only to be stopped by the backs and shoulders of its happy denizens.

Midtown Happy Hour: Subway Inn

Needless to say, I was overdue for a visit so I made my pilgrimage to Subway on a dreary early afternoon with a group of friends. Most of us had Yuengling, bottled, for $4.50. I also ordered a vodka and soda for $5. Some things have changed at the Subway. The owners took a swiffer to the place and added some arcade games and a nice large flat screen TV, but other charms are still the same. My girlfriend told us her story from the last time she was here drinking late: turns out there was a group of middle-agers drunk off their noodle and talking, laughing and dancing on the floor. One ‘chick’ was passed out with her head on the table when she suddenly started to hurl all over the tabletop. Her friends finally noticed and swabbed all the puke into an empty shopping bag then proceed to continue drinking and reveling long into the night.

For us it was still too early to see any thing like that, but as you know when drinking with a good group of friends it’s inevitable that you’ll stay later than you thought. Luckily, 2 storefronts down there is Mariella Pizza (151 E. 60th St). The place does good business and the manager loves to chat up every skirt that he rings up. In addition, he also willingly gives out his business card and yes ladies, he does indeed deliver, just call.

Midtown Happy Hour: Subway Inn

A friend and I ordered a meatball parm and a grandma slice to share for $9.50. I would normally say that this place is good for convenient beer ballast, but not anything I’d walk too far for. However, that would put me at odds with Oprah and Gayle who apparently think that Mariella has the best pizza in America!! Well then, I take it all back! Sign me up for that book club too!!!

The last thing I’ll leave you gentle readers with is this: Ladies employ your best hover technique when going to the loo. The wooden seat has seen the wear and tear of what I dare not imagine and as a public service I don’t want you to get splinters.

THE + (What somebody who likes this place would say)

  • Directly outside the subway entrance: Perfect for your drunken yet stealthy escape!
  • Decent drinking value considering the mink fur clad are at your door
  • Lunchtime martini(s) with little chance of getting caught by the boss? You bet!!
  • Ball and Chain want to drag you along for shopping at Bloomys? Perfect! (“Um yeah, I’m just going to look at the men’s department honey”)
  • THE - (What somebody who doesn’t like this place would say)

  • Smelly old dive bar (oddly enough the bar smells worse than the can… at least in the afternoon
  • Hygienically Dubious!
  • I am not sitting in that booth!
  • Subway Inn, 143 E. 60th St. (btw. Lex+3rd Ave.)

    Photos and post by Mamacita


    • good to know nothing’s really changed, though i don’t really remember much from the day i went there.

      wait, Gayle lives in New York? I thought she lived with Opie on one of their many estates.

    • Small, dark and dirty is how I imagine many of you in my mind’s eye.

    • Love the Fact you said “loo” instead of the bloody silly “Restroom”.

      Chuckwit,if brains we’re C4 you wouldn’t have enough to blow your bloody nose.

    • More teeth than brains Chucky. Smile you arse.

    • My dearest “UpchuckSpice” (which I doubt is your real name):

      This —-> http://photos.aim.com/photos/6a350628-d753-11dd-a829-000bcdcb471e/22021410

      was in very poor taste.

      Oprah and Gayle would not approve.

    • Mamacita–do you follow me after work or something?? Wtf? Why you gotta out all my hangouts!!!!??? God forbid some of those profiled Tuesdayers disgrace my sacred watering holes!

      Subway Inn is a classic—much like Village Idiot was before the suits took it over by raising the rent and running it out of business. Patriot Bar and Yogi’s don’t compare to the old VI.

      If you write about Desmonds next or my beloved McCormacks, I’m seriously gonna hunt you down! LOL

    • Desmonds was already on my list! HA! I am stalking you!
      But what’s worth eating at McCormacks?

    • McCormacks (26th on 3rd) actually has decent food–nothing extraordinary–but always solid and above avg for bar food. Not bad prices either. It’s not “really cheap” and it’s not quite “divey” enough to make this list, and sometimes the Brit pop that is almost always played gets on my nerves, but the bartenders are cool and it’s always a good time. Usually every third is comped–and they often let the regulars (me) stay well past closing…and sometimes, late night, they let you smoke in the bar (GASP!). I have seen the sun come up from there one, or one hundred too many times….

    • Dr. Charles, Phd, M.D., what is your favorite style of beer? I’m partial to IPAs and pale ales.

    • I am partial to being fully drunk before noon whatever libations I can guzzle down that are readily available. The wife likes a good box of wine of superior vintage, last spring. The two of us get real boozed up and make prank phone calls and send faxes. You should try it sometime. Block your phone number, people get a bit upset with the faxes, believe me -LOL

    • Thats the fucking bomb dude!

    • Hygenically dubious? Oh come on now…Rudys is faaar crustier than the Subway. the Inn is a true Classic Dive – its also a great place to kill time during rush hour if you ride the N/W into queens like I do!

    • The garlic knots at Mariella are great.

    Leave a Reply

    You must log in or register to post a comment.