Home » Forums » New York City » Midtown Eating

WHOA: Uncle Gussy's

Shivery.McPickles

You guys. I feel like an idiot. I have a week and a half left at my current job and I JUST tried Uncle Gussy's. What have I been thinking all this time??

Their rice is clearly not special, but their lamb is SO good. And their white sauce has YOGURT in it. I'm in love.

ADVERTISEMENT

17 Comments

  1. Steve

    never heard of it.

  2. monstermooch
  3. StreetMeasOnsumer3008
  4. Mamacita
  5. monstermooch
  6. StreetMeasOnsumer3008

    Oh the greek cart!
    It's right in front of my office, silly me.
    I ate there ONCE like my first week working in midtown and never again. LOL.

  7. Shivery.McPickles

    I'm not alone in missing this completely so far? It's on 51st and Park, as Monstermooch said, by the BofA.

    $5 for chicken and lamb on rice with gyro style lamb shaved off a rotisserie and pretty tasty tzatziki. Their hot sauce is a little on the vinegary side, but I DID ask for extra because I am... just that way.

    Dudes. It's good.

  8. StreetMeasOnsumer3008

    Yea, don't be like me walking to Carnegie John's instead when there's a greek cart right in front of me. I thought their food was only okay. Tzatziki helps.

  9. mkim1206

    oh goodie..i gotta try this place, thanks.
    btw, gussy is my nick name.

  10. Shivery.McPickles

    I mean, StreetMeas, Carnegie John's is just... different. And definitely worth the walk. But when it's cold and yucky and you just need a fix, Uncle Gussy's is pretty good option.

    Also: I'm going to need Columbus Circle area recommends pretty soon since I've finally succeeded in getting myself out of my soul-suck of a job!

  11. StreetMeasOnsumer3008

    In good faith, I'll eat it again, Pickles. This time, just the lamb rice with Tzatziki and hot sauce.

    It's definitely better than succumbing to Rafiqi's nearby (probably the main reason I don't like eating at carts directly in front of my office).

  12. Shivery.McPickles

    Yeah. Street meat + corn = suspicious Pickles.

  13. Mamacita

    McP, where about columbus circle?

Reply »

You must log in to post.